Website Exclusive: Fowl Play The Wineville Coop of Corpses

Welcome back, creeps and creepettes, it’s your old pal Mr. Cemetery, clawing my way out of the grave with another TRUE spine-chilling tale to make your blood curdle and your bones rattle!

Tonight, we’re digging up a real ghoul-ash of a true story from the sun-scorched fields of Wineville, California, where a chicken coop turned into a coop de grace for innocent souls. Picture a twisted farm where the eggs weren’t the only things cracking, and a fiend with a heart colder than a crypt lured boys to a fate more fowl than you can imagine.

What kind of monster hides behind a farmer’s smile, and what horrors lie buried in the dirt? Stick around, if you dare, to find out!

Now then, on tonight’s story, I call this one Fowl Play: The Wineville Coop of Corpses enjoy, hahahhahaha!

In the dusty outskirts of Southern California, where the sun baked the earth into cracked, unforgiving soil and the air hung heavy with the scent of dry brush and distant ocean salt, a sleepy little town called Wineville sprawled like a forgotten dream. It was the late 1920s, a time when Hollywood’s glamour lights flickered just over the hills, drawing dreamers to the city while farmers like the Northcotts scratched out a living from the land. But beneath the surface of this rural idyll lurked a nightmare so grotesque it would stain the soil forever, turning a simple chicken ranch into a chamber of unspeakable horrors.

Gordon Stewart Northcott arrived in America from Canada in 1924, a young man of just 18 with a sharp jawline and eyes that seemed to hold shadows too deep for his age. Born in the harsh prairies of Saskatchewan and raised in British Columbia, Gordon had always been an odd one—whispers followed him back home, tales of inappropriate touches and strange affections toward the neighborhood boys. His family, desperate perhaps to give him a fresh start, emigrated to Los Angeles. There, Gordon convinced his father, Cyrus, a sturdy contractor, to buy a plot of arid land in Wineville, Riverside County. With dreams of raising chickens and living off the land, Gordon built a modest house and outbuildings, including a large chicken coop that stood like a sentinel amid the scrub. But the ranch was more than a farm; it was a isolated haven, far from prying eyes, where the wind whispered secrets through the wire fences and the nights stretched black and endless.

To help with the work, Gordon sent for his nephew, Sanford Clark, a lanky 13-year-old boy from back in Canada. Sanford arrived in 1926, wide-eyed and eager to prove himself, but what awaited him was no uncle’s warm welcome. From the moment Sanford stepped onto the ranch, Gordon’s demeanor shifted. The boy was subjected to brutal physical beatings—whippings with belts and switches until his skin split open—and worse, a relentless sexual abuse that twisted Sanford’s world into a prison of fear. Gordon kept him under constant watch, chaining him at night and forcing him to labor by day, all while murmuring threats of what would happen if he ever tried to run. “You’re mine now,” Gordon would hiss, his voice low and venomous, as the chickens clucked indifferently in their coops. Sanford, terrified and isolated, became Gordon’s unwilling accomplice, his spirit broken like the dry twigs underfoot.

The abductions began quietly, almost unnoticed amid the bustle of Los Angeles. Young boys, vulnerable and alone, started vanishing from the streets. In February 1928, a headless body of a teenage boy—later identified as Alvin Gothea, a Mexican youth who’d been working as a ranch hand—was found in a ditch near La Puente, shot through the heart with a .22-caliber rifle and stuffed into a burlap sack. The authorities chalked it up to a random tragedy, but Gordon knew better. He’d lured the boy to the ranch under false pretenses, assaulted him repeatedly, and when the teen became too much trouble, ended his life with a single, cold shot. The body was dumped far away, but the bloodstains lingered in the dirt of the chicken coop, where Gordon had dragged him for his final moments.

Then came Walter Collins, a bright-eyed 9-year-old from Lincoln Heights in Los Angeles. On March 10, 1928, Christine Collins, a telephone operator and single mother, handed her son a dime for the movies and watched him skip off toward the theater. Walter never returned. Christine waited through the evening, her worry turning to panic as night fell. She reported him missing to the Los Angeles Police Department, but the LAPD, embroiled in scandals of corruption and inefficiency, dragged their feet. The city was growing too fast, the streets too crowded with transients and dreamers; one missing boy seemed like just another statistic. But Christine wouldn’t let it go. She plastered posters everywhere, her face gaunt with desperation, pleading for any sighting of her “little man.”

Unbeknownst to her, Walter had been snatched by Gordon, who spotted the boy wandering alone and enticed him with promises of adventure or candy—lures as old as sin itself. Back at the ranch, Walter was thrown into the chicken coop, a filthy enclosure reeking of feathers, manure, and now terror. Gordon’s assaults were savage; he bound the boy, violated him over days, his laughter echoing like a demon’s as Walter begged for mercy. Sanford, forced to witness it all, huddled in the corner, his stomach churning with bile. Gordon would make him watch, whispering, “This is what happens to little birds who stray too far.” When news of the search for Walter intensified, Gordon panicked. His mother, Sarah Louise Northcott, a stern woman in her 50s who lived in Los Angeles but doted obsessively on her son, arrived unannounced for a visit. Sarah, who some whispered was more than just Gordon’s mother—rumors swirled of incestuous origins, that she was actually his grandmother after her husband raped their daughter—stumbled upon the scene.

Instead of horror, Sarah’s eyes gleamed with a twisted protectiveness. “We can’t let him talk,” she said, her voice steady as she proposed the unthinkable. To shield her precious boy, she suggested they all share the guilt: Gordon, Sanford, and herself. They led Walter from the coop into the dim light of the house, where Gordon handed out an ax. One by one, they struck—Sarah delivering the fatal blow to the boy’s skull, her face emotionless as blood sprayed across the floor. Walter’s small body slumped, his eyes forever frozen in betrayal. They dismembered him hastily, wrapping the pieces in burlap and burying them in shallow graves near the coop, doused in quicklime to hasten decay and hide the evidence. The quicklime hissed as it ate into the flesh, a chemical funeral pyre under the stars. Sanford vomited into the dirt, but Gordon just smiled, wiping the ax clean. “Now he’s part of the farm,” he said.

The Winslow brothers followed in May 1928. Nelson, 10, and Lewis, 12, were walking home from a model yacht club meeting in Pomona when Gordon spotted them. He offered them a ride in his old car, his friendly facade cracking only when they reached the ranch. Like Walter, they were herded into the coop, subjected to unspeakable violations that left them broken and weeping. Gordon toyed with them for days, forcing Sanford to participate in the rapes under threat of death. “Help me, or you’re next,” he’d growl, pressing a knife to the boy’s throat. When the brothers’ disappearance made headlines, Gordon decided it was time. He marched them to the incubator room, where fluffy chicks peeped innocently in their shells—a cruel distraction to calm their sobs. Then, with the ax raised high, he brought it down. Thwack. Thwack. Blood mingled with eggshells, the air thick with the metallic tang of death. The bodies were hacked apart, heads severed to prevent identification, and buried in the same lime-filled pits as Walter’s. Fragments of bone and clothing would later be unearthed, but the full horror remained buried with them.

How many more? Gordon boasted of up to 20 victims, boys lured from the streets of Los Angeles or snatched from migrant camps. There was talk of another headless youth in the desert, perhaps one of his earlier kills, but the true count dissolved into the shadows of his madness. Sanford, scarred and silent, helped dispose of the remains, his hands trembling as he shoveled dirt over the quicklime-sizzled graves. The chicken coop became a tomb, its wire walls whispering with the ghosts of the lost.

The unraveling began in August 1928, when Sanford’s older sister, Jessie, 19 and sharp-witted, visited from Canada. Concerned by letters that hinted at trouble, she arrived at the ranch to find her brother gaunt and haunted, bruises blooming like dark flowers on his arms. Away from Gordon’s watchful eyes, Sanford broke down, spilling the tale of abductions, assaults, and murders. “He’s killing them, Jessie—one after another,” he sobbed, describing the ax, the lime, the endless screams. Horrified, Jessie fled back to Canada and alerted the American consul, who wired the LAPD. Immigration officers were dispatched to the ranch, but Gordon spotted them approaching and bolted, dragging his mother along as they fled north to British Columbia.

Sanford stalled as ordered, his heart pounding, until the officers arrived. He led them to the coop, where the ground yielded its grim secrets: shallow pits with shards of bone, scraps of boys’ clothing soaked in blood, strands of hair clinging to rusted wire, and even a .22 rifle matching the one that killed Alvin Gothea. The quicklime had done its work, dissolving much, but enough remained to paint a picture of depravity. Gordon and Sarah were captured in Vernon, British Columbia, after a frantic border crossing. Extradited to California, they faced a media frenzy that turned Wineville into a synonym for evil.

The trials were a circus of confessions and contradictions. Sarah, ever the doting matriarch, pleaded guilty to Walter’s murder, claiming she wielded the ax to protect her son. “We all did it together,” she said coolly, sentenced to life in Tehachapi Women’s Prison. Sanford, deemed a victim coerced into complicity, was sent to Whittier State School for Boys but later released and returned to Canada, where he rebuilt a life haunted by nightmares. Gordon, now 22, defended himself in a Riverside courtroom, firing lawyers and spinning wild tales. He admitted to the molestations—“I loved them too much,” he smirked—but denied the killings, blaming his mother or phantom accomplices. He even dragged family secrets into the light, claiming incestuous bonds and childhood rapes by his father to explain his “condition.” The jury saw through it. On February 8, 1929, he was convicted of murdering the Winslow brothers and Alvin Gothea, sentenced to hang.

October 2, 1930, dawned gray at San Quentin State Prison. Gordon, trembling and pale, begged for a blindfold—“I don’t want to see it”—and a prayer as the noose tightened. The trap sprung, but the drop was botched; the rope stretched without snapping his neck. For 13 agonizing minutes, he strangled, his body twitching in the dawn light, until death claimed him. In his cell, a crude map was found, hinting at more graves, but searches turned up nothing—his final cruel jest.

Christine Collins never found Walter’s body; the quicklime had erased him. She fought the LAPD for years, exposing their attempt to foist an impostor boy on her to close the case, but the truth slipped away like smoke. Wineville, forever tainted, changed its name to Mira Loma in 1930, as if renaming the land could bury the ghosts. The chicken coop was razed, the ranch abandoned to weeds, but the echoes remain—whispers in the wind, reminding us that monsters don’t always lurk in the shadows; sometimes, they build farms and call them home.

Well, well, well, my little ghouls and goblins, it looks like the Wineville chicken coop wasn’t just clucking with poultry—it was a hen-ious slaughterhouse where Gordon Northcott’s twisted appetites hatched a nightmare!

Those poor boys never stood a chance against a monster who thought he could bury his sins in a quicklime grave. Talk about a fowl ending—proof that some farms grow nothing but despair, and the only thing free-range was a killer’s cruelty.

So, if you’re still shivering from this egg-sruciating tale, don’t keep it cooped up—share this episode with your friends, because misery loves company!

And don’t forget to check out the podcast on Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your screams, then subscribe for more terror that’ll make your heart skip a beat or three.

Got a creepy comment on this story? Should we record this for Terror Tales? Let me know in the comments below; I’m dying to hear it!

Until next time, remember: when you’re out wandering, steer clear of strange farms—unless you want to be the next one plucked! Hahahahahaha!